This was a dud and it had great potential. It’s the brush! I love this formula, it stays on regardless of what you do and it doesn’t fade. I have hooded eyelids so everything eventually rubs off, but this formula didn’t, it stayed put and didn’t rub or scuff.
Super pretty brush, you think, but imagine a plastic bristled tiny brush going in this tough, water-resistant goop application after application, it gets dungy and unrefined after the first use. You will not get a perfect line without a lot of eye makeup remove and Q-tips to smudge this on and remove it off in the shape you’d like.
I stopped using it and gave it to my sister. This formula needs to go into an applicator pencil of some type for it to keep a fine tip for proper application. The results are just rough:
I can make it look great, though:
I rank this drugstore liner a 4/10. It needs a better applicator, I cannot stress that enough, but the formula is impeccable. It stays on all day and then some in the shape you get it into.